Brothers Pizza

This evening was my first time eating at this restaurant with my husband. Before we even ate we spoke to a few customers there who said they loved eating at this restaurant and that the food was great. The crowds were coming in very strongly and I definitely noticed. The very strong reviews about the food are well deserved. We ordered a large Brothers special supreme pizza and a large pepperoni and Italian sausage pizza. Both were excellent. Nice and crispy crust. Fresh taste. Not too greasy. Great flavor. Big chunks of green peppers and other veggies on the Brothers special. I don't know why I didn't come here sooner.

I absolutely love this place. My fiance and I have pizza night about every two weeks, 2 large pizzas and sausage roll. I was born and raised for a portion of my life in New York and finding a quality NY style pizza is not easy in an area like this. They only take cash or check and their dining area is rather small. I only order for takeout but the inside seems a bit overwhelming to me when they’re busier.

I moved here from Wv about 5 hours away after my mom passed in 2021!! When I moved here, my kid brother introduced me to Brothers Pizza!!! It's becoming an every Friday thing after I'm done with my arrends for the day!! Best pizza around! I've been here 3 yrs now and have had pizza at other places and this guy tops them, and let's not forget the hippie rolls, Pliant and chewy pizza dough held sweet roasted peppers and onions and a smidge of mozzarella cheese wrapped in a thin baked breading of some type!!! My point is this place is great!! Great folks are always ready to fill your belly, so you leave feeling stuffed with great homemade ITALIAN food!!! Try the carot cake, the icing on the planet!!!

I saw it driving down Route 3 and was going to go to a big franchise pizza place to pick up some pizzas for dinner, but I saw this place hiding behind the Taco Bell and Mission BBQ at the Bragg Road strip mall. First time seeing this hole in the wall. It’s a no-nonsense place. A BIG thing. No cards accepted. Cash only. Tables piled next to each other, and there was barely enough room at the counter without bumping into each other. Every table was full when I walked in, and the place was a bit warm in the sunny afternoon. Behind the counter seems to be more of the same. Cramped and hot, but you can see the passion is there. The menu dominates your eyeline as soon as you walk in. You see the cooler full of beverages (including beer!) to the right, but they also have fountain drinks. Also, a dessert glass with sides sits on the counter. Even in the midafternoon, they were BUSY. Orders were coming in fast on the phone, so the lady at the counter took a few minutes to take my order. Two large pizzas with two toppings each, a salad, and a drink for my drive home was nearly $50. It was good that I had cash on me because I didn’t know about the no-card rule until I got to the counter. The food is a solid 7.7/10. It’s much better than big franchises but the atmosphere is awesome. Great people work there; it seems like a cool spot to hang out to have a pie.